Thursday, March 12, 2009

The Year My Sister Got Lucky (Jill Frost)

The Year My Sister Got Lucky By: Aimee Friedman, Scholastic In., 370 pages
I found this book at Boarders.
Summary: This is a story about two sisters who live in Manhattan and get uprooted to the rural city of Fir Lake. Katie(Katya) always wants her mom to treat her like she treats her older sister Michaela, but that changes when Katie leans what it's been like for her sister. Michaela settles into Fir Lake wonderfully, making new friends, dating the Quarter back, and she even becomes homecoming Queen, where in the mix of all that she forgets about her sister. Katie on the other hand doesn't settle in to well. She just wants her old life back and nothing to do with Fir Lake. Their mother was a ballerina when she was younger which is why Michaela and Katie are both into ballet, Michaela already having an acceptance into Julliard. Soon Katie learns that Michaela doesn't want to go to a college for dance, but to live on campus, and take actual college courses. This book is mainly about the ups and downs of friendship, sisterhood, and change.
The audience for this book is mainly for teenage girls becuase it deals with boys, friends, dance, moving to a new town, and sisterhood.
The style of this book is that everything is direct. She tells you flat out what is going on, what things look like and what the characters are like. She uses the language that teenagers use when Michaela and Katie talk, she makes it very real. She is descriptive so you can picture everything in your mind. "It's a dark gray and spindly, with a black roof that's pointed like a witch's hat and big windows that yawn like mouths. There's a front porch, a red mailbox, and a small patch of grass in front. Ivy creeps up around the windows, like it's eating the house alive. Talk about omens- I knew there was a reason 13 is an unlucky number." Page 64
Quote # One: " That was one way of looking at it," I say, amazed once again at the differences between my sister and me. I didn't want a single thing to change. But I suppose stopping change is like trying to stop the leaves from falling every autumn." Page 344. This quote struck me because it really shows that you can't change, change. Change will always happen just like the leaves always falling. Also the way she interpreted how the you can't stop the leaves from falling and that you can't change, change was a good analogy.
Quote # Two: "And you'll always be my sister," Michaela goes on. "But.. you're not my friend." I've never been stabbed, but I'm guessing this is how it feels. Page 217. This quote struck me because when you are close to a sibling and they always tell you everything, and then say you aren't friends, that you're just siblings, it probably hurts. The relationship between siblings is always a greater bond than relationships between friends. Just because you are siblings and not friends, doesn't mean they won't always be there for you.
Quote # Three: It feels weird to be admitting these truths and secrets, letting them all spill out. "And i thought you were a city snob," Autumn says in the same cheerful, plain manner. "Wearing all back on the first day of school... acting like you were too good to walk to Social Studies with me..." Page 207. This quote struck me because it shows how everybody judges everyone when they don't even know them. Katie judged Autumn, and Autumn judged Kate, and it turns out that everything they thought was wrong. You should try not to judge people before you even have a chance on meeting them.
I related to this book mainly becuase I have two older sisters. I can relate to the part where Michaela tells Katie they they are sisters and not friends becuase i don't consider my sisters my friends. I consider them my sisters and only my sisters. I think that way becuase i know my friends aren't always there for me, but my sisters and are they are always open to listen. Mainly this whole book spoke to me because there were so many things you can learn from it. There was so much change going on in this book and it actually can help you on what to do and what not to do when moving.

6 comments:

  1. I think that I would enjoy reading this book. I also have an older sister so I could probably relate to the part where one sister tells the other they are not friends, and also the other things in the book. I think I would relate to the book because I moved to a new place that I wanted nothing to do with and in the beginning had a hard time settling in. The passage where Micheala tells Katie they are sisters but not friends is very much like the relationship I have with my sister, it doesn't really have an effect on me because that is always how I have viewed my sister. Since I do have an older sister who is more outgoing than I am, and in general always seems to fit in I think I would have experienced some of the same things you had while reading the book. Amanda Tesini

    ReplyDelete
  2. I do think that this book seems like something i would enjoy. I love the classic, "girl" book, I also really enjoy reading books that have direct characterization I think its easier to read. I really like that one of the conflicts is adjusting to a new school and a new life. That makes it different from other teen books that just focus on one topic such as dating. I will read basically anything as long as the book seems like it will keep my interest, and make me want to keep reading it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This novel seems like a book that I would really enjoy.I like books that are very descriptive. They are very easy to understand so that's why I like when books are descriptive.I would relate to this book but not that much since my sister is younger.We have never told each other that we are not friends.We consider each other friends and sisters. The passages that you picked were really cool especially your 2 quote where the meaning was that change always happens just like leaves always fall in the fall.
    -Rosina Sinigur

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think I could relate to this book in more than one way. I have moved to new towns and had to meet new friends and it's very hard. I could also relate to the ups and downs of sisterhood very well. If I read this book I do think I would enjoy it, I love the girl drama books.

    AriLee Demakis

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've read another book by Aimee Friedman and i really enjoyed it. I think I could also relate to this book, just like everyone else said and it would be a book that i would enjoy reading. I don't have an older sister so i don't think i could really relate that way but the whole idea of the high school drama. I like the girlie books and i enjoy reading them. The passage "And i thought you were a city snob" relates to this town perfectly.

    ReplyDelete